Side-by-side
An honest comparison
with ReplyZen.
We respect ReplyZen. Here is how ROAS Shield is different for paid Meta ad-comment moderation — and where ReplyZen is still the better fit.
Feature comparison
ROAS Shield vs ReplyZen
Sourced from replyzen.ai as of May 2026, plus our own product. ReplyZen publishes no public price points; pricing is described as volume-based.
| Feature | ROAS Shield | ReplyZen | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built specifically for paid Meta ads | ReplyZen covers FB & IG comments on ads and organic posts (replyzen.ai FAQ, as of May 2026). | ||
| Ad-context columns in inbox (campaign, ad set, ad) | — | Ad-level attribution (campaign / ad set / ad) is the core ROAS Shield focus; ReplyZen does not document ad-creative-level mapping. | |
| Inverse creative lookup for unmapped comments | — | A ROAS Shield mechanism for mapping comments back to the ad that drew them. | |
| AI on-brand contextual replies | |||
| Comment-to-DM automation | |||
| UTM / conversion tracking on replies | ReplyZen markets conversion tracking on its AI replies (replyzen.ai, as of May 2026). | ||
| Multilingual replies + knowledge-base grounding | |||
| Published, transparent pricing | £19 / 10k → £199 / 500k | Volume-based (no public pricing) | ReplyZen publishes no price points; it lists volume-based pricing and a 14-day trial (replyzen.ai, as of May 2026). |
| Native Slack + Microsoft Teams alerts | — | ROAS Shield posts storm alerts and buyer-intent leads straight to a Slack or Teams channel. | |
| Read-only REST API + per-workspace keys | — | A scoped REST API for pulling your comments and leads into your own dashboards or client reports. |
Where they win
Where ReplyZen is the better fit
We are not the right tool for everyone. If any of the below applies to your team, ReplyZen might serve you better than we will.
Strong AI-reply + conversion-tracking story
ReplyZen leans into sales-style AI replies with UTM and conversion tracking — a strong fit for advertisers who want to attribute revenue to comment replies.
Comment-to-DM and knowledge-base grounding
On-brand contextual replies grounded in a knowledge base, plus comment-to-DM automation, make it well suited to teams optimising for conversation-to-sale.
TikTok beta
Per its own site, ReplyZen has a TikTok beta — coverage beyond Meta that we do not offer in v1.
Our wedge
Where we believe ROAS Shield wins
Ad-first by design
Every comment in the inbox shows campaign, ad set, and ad context. You can filter by campaign, see which ads attract spam, and tune rules per-ad. Generic comment moderators do not foreground which ad a comment is on.
Volume pricing for paid-ads teams
Our Scale tier is £199 per month for up to 500,000 comments. Predictable, volume-based pricing for high-spend advertisers — not per-seat.
Honest UI on the rough edges
When we cannot map a comment back to its ad, we say so and surface a manual-mapping action — including an inverse creative lookup. We do not paper over Meta API gaps with confident-looking UI.
Closed loops, not just moderation
Storm alerts and buyer-intent leads reach you in Slack or Microsoft Teams the moment they happen. Won leads roll up into an influenced-revenue figure on the dashboard and the weekly digest, and a read-only REST API pulls your comments and leads into your own reporting — detection through to proof, end to end.
Run the numbers on your own ad spend
Pricing scales with comment volume, not seats. Start a 7-day trial without a card.